Latest Podcast



Featured Articles

Friday, April 15, 2011

Maybe mobile phone tariffs aren't a rip-off after all

Mark Bridge writes:

Oh, those nasty mobile networks. They’re robbing us blind… at least, that’s what you might think if you’ve been reading the headlines this week.

Mobile users 'overpaying by £200', said the BBC. £5bn 'wasted' on mobile phone bills, said the Financial Times. It's the wrong tariff, Gromit!, said Telecom TV after hitting the Wensleydale.

The stories were based on a report from mobile tariff price comparison website Billmonitor.com. It calculated that 76% of UK mobile customers could be on a more cost-effective price plan, which meant mobile users were over-spending by an average of £194.71 each per year.

Tosh, I say. Many people are undoubtedly on inappropriate tariffs - but there are too many assumptions there.

Now, let me put my cards on the table. I used to work for a mobile network. And, as a freelance copywriter, I still work for mobile networks and mobile retailers. But I don’t think that invalidates my opinion any more than Billmonitor’s commercial activities invalidate theirs. So I’ll continue.

To start with, I’ll knock three-quarters of a billion quid off the total. The report says 19% of people on the ‘wrong contract’ have the right level of inclusive minutes but are either wasting money by not optimising free benefits, data and text allowances or other costs - or are missing out by not taking advantage of lower costs from longer contracts. So… if you signed an 18-month contract but could have got a better deal by committing to longer, you’re on the wrong tariff. Of course, if you’d signed a 24-month contract but your circumstances had changed, you’d be completely stuffed. That’s not something factored in to the calculations. Altogether, there’s a total of £740,000,000 that arguably isn’t really wasted at all. It’s no more ‘wasted’ than paying for insurance is wasted if you don’t claim.

What else isn’t in those calculations?  Not all network deals, such as discounts for specific numbers, are included. Fair usage allowances for ‘unlimited’ deals are missing too. And the Billmonitor calculator makes assumptions as well. However clever the maths, it can’t account for everything.

On top of all this, no-one seems to be admitting that customers are happy to pay for convenience. A ‘bundle’ of calls and texts isn’t merely a marketing ploy, it’s a consumer benefit. If you don’t want a call allowance, you don’t need to have one. In fact, you don’t even need to have a monthly mobile phone contract at all if you’d rather ‘pay as you go’.

Paying for convenience also sees us throwing away stale milk instead of keeping a cow - and not reading all of the Sunday paper because we don’t have time to do our own reporting.

Finally, I doubt that similar figures would have been given as much credence by the mainstream media if they'd been presented by spokespeople from other pricing comparison sites - such as Gio Gompario, Aleksandr Orlov or Omid Djalili.

Mobile network operators aren’t saints. But I don’t believe they’re con artists, either. That’s all I wanted to say, really.

Print
Author: The Fonecast
3 Comments
Rate this article:
No rating

Categories: Networks and operators, OpinionNumber of views: 23058

Tags: opinion tariff

3 comments on article "Maybe mobile phone tariffs aren't a rip-off after all"

0
0
Avatar image

Nick Wright

4/18/2011 9:51 AM

Hi Mark,

Just wanted to respond on behalf of billmonitor to your comments on our report and service.

First of all, thank you! It's really great to have some spirited debate about our numbers - personally, I'm in favour of robustly challenging them so we can explain our own reasoning more clearly wher necessary and where possible.

Regarding your point on 24-month contracts - it's a shame in some ways that the best value is only available with a 2-year commitment period. However, economically-speaking, there's no denying that 24-month contracts are always much better deals than 18-month ones.

Also - what exactly do you mean by change of circumstances? If you use your phone more: all networks allow you to move up a tariff. If you use it less, and need fewer minutes/texts/data: you are just as restricted on 18-month contracts as on 24-month ones. The only situation where a change of circumstances might hurt you 24 mo. vs. 18 mo. is if you're forced to a) move abroad - thus meaning you pay an additional 6 months you no longer need or b) move to an area with low reception on the network you chose and can't switch for an additional 6 months. In both cases, the additional costs of a 24-month contract would represent the probability you believe either a) or b) will occur multiplied by the amount you'd stand to lose. In most cases though, we believe, this is rare.

We do factor in fair usage allowances - where explicitly stated by networks. In most cases, the assumptions you state would have the affect of INCREASING the wastage - as it means we are overestimating customers' true costs/underestimating savings on new contracts we recommend (ie. they may pay EVEN less with discounts to specific numbers). We're working on improving accuracy all the time but round up not down when estimating future costs, erring on the side of caution.

Unfortunately, I have to flatly disagree with your argument about convenience on contract deals being a rational reason for the waste. billmonitor builds in significant probabilisitic error margins when calculating customers' ideal tariff allowance levels. While I agree that customers on post-pay prefer convenience over exact metering - our wider point is that customers go WAY too far in overestimating their monthly usage, to the extent that they are wasting money. To reiterate: 13 million subscribers have 4 times too many minutes for their usage (ie. they use on average just a quarter of their allowance). Those who have a comfortable amount of minutes use on average half of their minutes. I would say that is still a decent margin for convenience.

To use your own metaphor: I agree, keeping a cow is not convenient. But the correct comparison would be buying a pint of milk a week and letting three quarters of it go rancid by the end of the week. Why not buy a half pint (or even a quarter pint)? Buying too much when less will do is by definition wasteful.

Finally, we never put the blame on networks per se. This is a complex space for customers with multiple variables. If networks simplified they may be reducing choice or flexibility, which is also not desirable. The correct solution is more guided decision-making using impartial expert advice, choice tools and crowd-sourced customer feedback.


0
0
Avatar image

The Fonecast

4/18/2011 9:49 AM

Thanks for your comments, Nick. I'm very happy to be proved wrong by the maths!


0
0
Avatar image

Nick Wright

4/18/2011 10:17 AM

You're welcome! Feel free to keep calling us out on our stats, if you're in any doubt. We prefer to operate in an environment of rigorous peer-review where possible as it keeps our own product and approach honest and open.

Leave a comment

This form collects your name, email, IP address and content so that we can keep track of the comments placed on the website. For more info check our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use where you will get more info on where, how and why we store your data.
Add comment

Opinion Articles

How AI technology is transforming the smartphone experience

How AI technology is transforming the smartphone experience

From improved performance to personalized recommendations, AI is enhancing the functionality and usability of smartphones for users

By incorporating advanced algorithms and machine learning capabilities, AI can help to optimize a smartphone's performance, providing users with a faster, more efficient and user-friendly experience.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
Whatever happened to all my tech?

Whatever happened to all my tech?

Mark Bridge revisits his mobile technology reviews

Mark Bridge writes:

I've been taking a look back at the devices I've written about during the past few years. Some are still faithful companions, others... well, let's just say my faith was misplaced.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Predictions for 2016: Network Function Virtualisation, 4G throttling and video calling

Mark Windle, head of marketing at OpenCloud, predicts that this year’s reduction in the number of traditional telecoms operators in some countries will provide an opportunity for other operators to innovate and capture market share in 2016.

He says next year will be a year of rapid change for telecoms… whether it’s MVNO disruption, competitive tariff pricing or simply defence from the ‘dark art’ of hacking.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
Kapture review: the audio-recording wristband

Kapture review: the audio-recording wristband

A 'recording watch' that links to your smartphone

Mark Bridge writes:

The most memorable moments in life often go unrecorded. You don't have your camera in your hands. Your finger is still hovering over the 'pause' button on your audio recorder. Or you were simply too busy experiencing whatever was happening. It's all about the one that got away.

That's where Kapture can help.

Author: The Fonecast
4 Comments
Article rating: 4.0
Making mobile websites work better

Making mobile websites work better

Device detection and responsive design explained

Mark Bridge writes:

James Rosewell shows me a colourful roll of paper that's the width of an iPhone but well over three metres long. When I look closer, I can see it's a printed copy of the Wall Street Journal's mobile website. That's a lot of scrolling to do... and a pretty unfriendly user experience for anyone reading the news online. Why does it work so badly?

Author: The Fonecast
1 Comments
Article rating: 4.0
RSS
12345678910Last

Recent Podcasts

The week's top mobile industry news stories, from Motorola to malware

Podcast - 5th February 2014

This week's podcast starts with Lenovo's purchase of the Motorola Mobility smartphone business. Was it a good deal for everyone?

We also talk about network infrastructure sharing in the UK, mobile malware, 3G coverage, misleading apps, mobile advertising, Samsung's retail plans and global tablet sales.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Mobile network disagreements, unexpected price rises, patents, takeovers and 4G data

Podcast - 29th January 2014

We start this week's podcast by looking at the new Ofcom rules that should end unexpected mid-contract price rises for UK mobile phone customers.

There's also talk about misleading mobile network advertising, patent agreements, takeover bids, satellite broadband and 4G data usage... plus a curious patent application from Google.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Mobile payments, connected contact lenses, secure smartphones and much more

Podcast - 22nd January 2014

In this week's podcast, James Rosewell and Mark Bridge talk about the new Zapp mobile payment scheme, Google's healthcare plans and an ultra-secure smartphone.

Also on the agenda are HP's new phablets, Jimmy Wales joining a UK MVNO, Apple's in-app purchases and plenty of research about tablets.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Google acquires Nest, O2 closes its Wallet, SMS usage falls... plus the rest of the week's mobile industry news

Podcast - 15th January 2014

This week's podcast starts with talk about money, as Google buys smart thermostat company Nest Labs while O2 UK closes its mobile Wallet product.

We're also looking at the decline of SMS text messaging in the UK, the end of the Cash4phones recycling business, an alleged security breach that wasn't what it seemed, mobile service on the Channel tunnel and the growth of 4G.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Predictions for 2014 and beyond with Florent Stroppa of OnMobile

Podcast - 10th January 2014

Mark Bridge talks to Florent Stroppa, General Manager Europe for mobile value-added service specialist OnMobile.

In today's programme Florent explains what 2014 holds for the mobile industry, what he thinks will happen in the slightly more-distant future - and what lessons we can learn from 2013.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
RSS
First89101113151617Last

Follow thefonecast.com

Twitter @TheFonecast RSS podcast feed
Find us on Facebook Subscribe free via iTunes

Archive Calendar

«March 2024»
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
26272829123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567

Archive

Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement