| Login
 
 

Published on Monday, May 16, 2011

The Council of Europe and its plans to ’ban mobile phones in schools’

Mark Bridge writes:

Europe’s leaders want mobile phones and WiFi networks banned in schools. Well, that’s what the headlines appear to say.

Except - as often seems to be the case with most mobile phone health warnings - things aren’t that simple. So let’s start at the beginning.

The Council of Europe has been around for over 60 years. It has 47 member countries and is concerned with democratic principles, from human rights to safer medicines. It’s probably best known for being the organisation behind the European Court of Human Rights. However, as an organisation, it can only advise and doesn’t make laws. It’s not the European Union, it’s not the European Parliament and (despite the similar name) it’s not the European Council.

Having said that, its opinions tend to be listened to by European legislators. You’ll often find references to PACE - the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe - in EU and EC documents.

Right, so that’s the CoE. Now to those headlines.

The CoE’s Committee on the Environment, Agriculture and Local and Regional Affairs has recently published a report entitled The potential dangers of electromagnetic fields and their effect on the environment. In that report (which is dated 6th May but has only been picked up by the media in the past few days) the committee proposes a draft resolution that recommends taking “all reasonable measures to reduce exposure to electromagnetic fields, especially to radio frequencies from mobile phones, and particularly the exposure to children and young people”. It goes on to propose banning “all mobile phones, DECT phones or WiFi or WLAN systems from classrooms and schools” and also anticipates legislation to “to keep high-voltage power lines and other electric installations at a safe distance from dwellings”. It wants to act in this way because “waiting for high levels of scientific and clinical proof can lead to very high health and economic costs”.

From one perspective this sounds like “shoot first, ask questions after”. From another, it’s designed to protect us from an unknown and as-yet-unproven danger. Others would suggest there’s no evidence any kind of action is needed.

However, before we start writing headlines about bans, let’s consider what this document is. It’s a report that is being passed to the Parliamentary Assembly for approval… or otherwise. At this stage, it doesn’t represent the views of the Council of Europe. And even if it did, the European Commission has already made its own somewhat less-controversial views about electromagnetic radiation perfectly clear.

If the Council of Europe makes any recommendations about mobile phones, WiFi and health, we ought to pay attention.

Until then, let’s not get too carried away.

Rate this article:
No rating
Comments (0)Number of views (457)
Print

0 comments on article "The Council of Europe and its plans to 'ban mobile phones in schools'"

0
0

Concerned Parent

5/16/2011 6:16 PM

The content of this Council of Europe report is consistent with the two EU Parliament resolutions adopted in 2008 and 2009, at near-unanimous votes which stated: “wireless technology (mobile phones, Wi-Fi / WiMAX, Bluetooth, DECT landline telephones) emits EMFs that may have adverse effects on human health... particularly to young people whose brains are still developing”.
"...the limits on exposure to electromagnetic fields which have been set for the general public are obsolete. They do not take account of developments in information and communication technologies or vulnerable groups, such as pregnant women, newborn babies and children."
the EU Parliament "calls on the Member States to follow the example of Sweden and to recognize persons that suffer from electrohypersensitivity as being disabled so as to grant them adequate protection as well as equal opportunities."

www.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/FindByProcnum.do?lang=en&procnum=INI/2008/2211
www.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/FindByProcnum.do?lang=en&procnum=INI/2007/2252

We commend the COE for bringing the health risks of wireless technology to the public. While researching the medical literature available, we found that most of the studies denying health effects are funded fully or partially by the industries, while there are thousands of independent studies indicating biological effects from wireless radiation. We don't think it's prudent to put children daily under Wi-Fi in schools, relying on the industry's claim that it's safe (and not grant children and parents the option to be not exposed). In Germany (Frankfurt, Bavaria) and Austria (Salzburg), hardwired computers are used. Not Wi-Fi. In Switzerland, hardwired broadband is even provided for free to primary and secondary schools by Swisscom, so that their students can enjoy cutting-edge education without the risk of microwave radiation.

in 2004, Swisscom had already learned the health implications of electromagnetic frequencies emitted by Wi-Fi. Therefore, they re-designed the Wi-Fi router and filed a patent for a safer, auto-shut-off design which would reduce (but not eliminate) microwave radiation by pulsing only when data is requested. Unfortunately, this patent has not been widely used by other countries, possibly due to cost concerns.

The genotoxic effects of wireless radiation are explained in the official Swisscom patent document. (Click "Description")
www.wipo.int/pctdb/en/wo.jsp?WO=2004075583&IA=CH2003000138&DISPLAY=STATUS


0
0

The Fonecast

5/20/2011 10:51 PM

RCR Wireless reports the European Commission's response: bit.ly/lMiLVD

Leave a comment

Name:
Email:
Comment:
CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above in the box below
Add comment
Opinion Articles

Thursday, August 28, 2014

Location based services - why operators hold all the cards

Donald Stuart, CEO of Brainstorm, explains why mobile operators are well placed to take advantage of the revenue streams opened up by location technologies.

The area of Location based services (LBS) has been getting a lot of attention of late, and it’s no wonder, Juniper Research has highlighted that the Mobile Context and Location Services market is expected to generate revenue of $43.4 billion by 2019, up from $12.2 billion in 2014.

Monday, August 25, 2014

Looking forward to Apps World 2014

Mark Bridge writes:

We’re delighted to be a media partner to Apps World 2014. This year Apps World has outgrown its previous home and is moving to ExCeL London, alongside the River Thames. There’ll be over 350 exhibitors and even more workshops than before, with a number of free conference sessions alongside premium options.

Friday, August 08, 2014

I'm trying to end the purple reign of my HTC One

Mark Bridge writes:

The two-year mobile phone contract has almost become a standard, despite EU efforts to make it a worst-case scenario. I went into the Brighton branch of Carphone Warehouse today and was told I couldn't upgrade to a 12-month contract. Last year I could; now they would only offer me a 24-month deal.

RSS
 
Recent Podcasts

Wednesday, July 30, 2014

We review the CAT B100 rugged mobile phone

Podcast - 30th July 2014

Mark Bridge takes an in-depth look at the CAT B100 rugged phone from Bullitt Mobile.

The CAT B100 is designed to withstand rather more than everyday bumps and knocks - which is why Mark drops his mobile phone on the pavement, submerges it in his washing-up bowl and shuts it in the freezer.

Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Microsoft cuts its mobile staff, Apple finds a new partner and Yahoo! makes an acquisition

Podcast - 23rd July 2014

We start this week's podcast with news that thousands of Microsoft's ex-Nokia employees are losing their jobs.

Other topics for discussion include the new Apple and IBM partnership, Yahoo's acquisition of Flurry, regulating mobile games, improving rural mobile coverage, BT's new phone service and some management movements.

Friday, July 18, 2014

Florent Stroppa of OnMobile talks about the state of the mobile telecom industry, from network deals to smart wearables

Podcast - 18th July 2014

In this podcast Mark Bridge talks to Florent Stroppa from mobile value-added service specialist OnMobile about the state of the mobile industry in 20014.

They discuss the dominance of Apple and Samsung, network consolidation, the new Amazon Fire smartphone, smart wearables and much more.

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

National security, phones for children, a new UK mobile network and a change of name

Podcast - 16th July 2014

This week's mobile industry podcast begins with a quick look at the UK government's emergency legislation affecting fixed-line, mobile phone and broadband traffic.

We then talk about Microsoft's plans, a new virtual network from the Post Office, Samsung's renamed app store, budget 4G smartphones, a wearable phone for children and some misleading advertising.

Wednesday, July 09, 2014

The week's biggest mobile industry news stories, from flying smartphones to falling profits

Podcast - 9th July 2014

We have a varied collection of mobile industry news stories in this week's podcast, including new rules affecting airline passengers with smartphones.

We also talk about BlackBerry giving up its European research centre, Vodafone installing fibre-optic broadband, Samsung's profits, spending on mobile advertising, M2M adoption and WiFi on trains.

RSS