Latest Podcast



Featured Articles

Ofcom says mobile contracts should ditch inflation-related price rises

Ofcom says mobile contracts should ditch inflation-related price rises

UK telecoms regulator Ofcom wants to ban inflation-related rises in phone and broadband contracts. Instead, it says any potential mid-contract price rises should be set out in pounds and pence.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Global smartphone market is set for recovery, says new forecast

A new forecast from research specialists Canalys shows the smartphone market is set to recover next year. Worldwide shipments declined by 12% last year but that decline is expected to slow to 5% this year.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
Vodafone and Three plan to merge their UK businesses

Vodafone and Three plan to merge their UK businesses

New Hutchison/Vodafone network would be biggest UK operator

Vodafone Group plc and CK Hutchison Group Telecom Holdings Limited have agreed to combine their UK telecommunication businesses, respectively Vodafone UK and Three UK. The merger will create a large new network operator to compete with Virgin Media O2 and EE.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

UK mobile payment service Paym to close in March 2023

UK mobile payment service Paym will close on 7th March 2023. The service, which allowed users to make and receive payments using their mobile phone numbers, was launched in 2014.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
Qualcomm legal action moves forward in the UK

Qualcomm legal action moves forward in the UK

Which? seeks payout for Samsung and Apple smartphone owners

Consumer protection organisation Which? has been given permission by the UK's Competition Appeal Tribunal to represent Apple and Samsung smartphone buyers in a legal case against chip manufacturer Qualcomm.
Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
RSS

Opinion Articles

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

SpinVox visit offers a few clues about the technology

Mark Bridge writes:

So, dear reader, let’s start at the beginning. Once upon a time, a mere five years ago, there was SpinVox. A company created with help from entrepreneur Christina Domecq – whose surname offers a clue to her family’s background – and Daniel Doulton, the man behind the Psion series 5. (Sherry and portable computers; two of my favourite products. But I digress).

The company’s promise was simple: to turn voicemail messages into SMS text messages.

As I see it, they created a service that was designed to evolve as technology did. My assumption is that pretty much every message would be heard by human operators in the early days – but as voice-to-text translation improved, more and more messages would be handled by computers.

Of course, the company didn’t want its customers to think their messages were being heard by call centre staff. That's the job of Vodafone’s Respond Plus service. So it talked about messages only being heard by humans when the technology wasn’t able to decipher them… without mentioning that its technology really didn’t understand that much.

Some people believed this meant that most voice messages were turned into SMS by computers. Some didn’t.

And then, one foul day, mocoNews interviewed Christina Domecq and asked about that conversion process. They said “I assumed the service worked purely by algorithm, but apparently there’s a lot of human transcription”. Next, before you knew it, Rory Cellan-Jones from the BBC was also on the case. People started talking about data protection and finances as well.

Anyway, to cut a long story short, SpinVox issued a couple of statements in an attempt to defuse the situation and then - when the BBC didn't go away quietly - invited a crowd of techy people to see what was happening. They weren’t allowed to record anything, just to watch, ask questions and play with the technology.

That visit took place yesterday. I’d have loved to have been there but I’m on holiday this week and didn’t get an invitation anyway. Not that I wouldn’t mind a visit next time. But I digress. Again.

The media response – which, I’m sure is the bit you’re interested in – is what I’d describe as “towards the negative end of mixed”. It looks like those techy people didn’t get any answers to the questions that had been bothering them. The big one is “What percentage of calls are handled by operators?” – and SpinVox says it’s commercially sensitive.

Milo Yiannopoulos from TechCrunch left a test message and was surprised to discover that “the agent in the room had to listen to and manually type the entire message, from beginning to end”. Not a single word was apparently translated by the computer system, although company CIO Rob Wheatley had successfully demonstrated SpinVox’s speech-to-text technology earlier in the day. In fact, The Register pointed out that all of the day’s test messages except Rob Wheatley’s demo required manual interpretation “pretty much in their entirety”. And that’s to say nothing of the awkward financial questions they wanted answered.

Which, in summary, means we’ve probably not seen the last SpinVox headline this year – or even this month.

Print
Author: The Fonecast
5 Comments
Rate this article:
No rating

Categories: OpinionNumber of views: 12304

Tags:

5 comments on article "SpinVox visit offers a few clues about the technology"

0
0
Avatar image

Steorm

8/6/2009 7:05 AM

Your narrative provides a pretty good summary, but what led to the MocoNews interview a couple weeks ago was that the company, which had raised $200m, was asking employees to take stock instead of salary because it was running out of cash.

It was the abiility to raise so much money that made Christina Domecq and SpinVox so famous in the first place. Exactly like her disasterous experience a few years earlier in the US where should got national press coverage for raising funds to start a new business, only to see it crash into bankruptcy. www.allbusiness.com/government/government-bodies-offices-law-courts-tribunals/10602370-1.html


0
0
Avatar image

Mark

8/6/2009 7:05 AM

Ben & Dan from The Really Mobile Project have just published a report on their visit. They say "The presentation and demo made no attempt to address the most serious allegations against SpinVox", "The demo, even under controlled circumstances, failed to demonstrate anything more than very basic automated transcription"and "We are amazed they believed this demonstration would support their claims and even more amazed they chose only to focus on the technical". thereallymobileproject.com/2009/08/spinvox-demo-day/


0
0
Avatar image

Mark

8/9/2009 10:51 AM

James Middleton from telecoms.com was in the second group of attendees: www.telecoms.com/13439/spinvox-behind-the-spin
He ends his report "I’ve come away feeling that SpinVox is much more reliant on humans than it would have you believe, and if that is the case, I have doubts as to whether it has a scalable and cost effective business model".


0
0
Avatar image

Mark

8/10/2009 3:56 PM

The BBC reports on a "dossier alleging financial irregularities", adding "It is thought the company has called in accounting consultants and lawyers to investigate the allegations".
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/8193263.stm


0
0
Avatar image

The Fonecast

8/19/2009 8:49 AM

The BBC's Rory Cellan-Jones sums up his recent thoughts about SpinVox: www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/technology/2009/08/spinvox_why_it_matters.html

Leave a comment

This form collects your name, email, IP address and content so that we can keep track of the comments placed on the website. For more info check our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use where you will get more info on where, how and why we store your data.
Add comment

Recent Podcasts

The week's top mobile news stories: Vodafone expands, EE celebrates and Europe prepares

Podcast - 19th March 2014

We begin this week's programme by looking at Vodafone's acquisition plans in Spain before moving on to discuss universal mobile chargers and 4G roaming.

There's also time to talk about UK mobile coverage, EE's new customer tracking service, contactless transactions and a smartphone camera that can identify objects hidden behind something else.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Johan Lodenius of MediaTek talks about wearable devices, smartphone evolution and the importance of driving costs down

Podcast - 13th March 2014

This year's Mobile World Congress was notable for the number of product launches by handset manufacturers. To get a better understanding of smartphone manufacturing, we spoke to Johan Lodenius of semiconductor company MediaTek.

He gave us a simple overview of how 'fabless' manufacturing works, discussed developments in smartphones and wearable devices, contemplated the end of the PC era and talked about the importance of driving costs down.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

Mobile payments, new smartphones, wearable devices, connected cars, CeBIT and David Cameron

Podcast - 12th March 2014

This week's programme opens with a quick look at David Cameron's commitment to 5G technology and the Internet of Things, which was made in a speech at CeBIT.

Iain and Mark then move on to talk about the other big mobile news headlines from the past few days, including the forthcoming Paym m-payment service, new HTC and LG smartphones, the growth of Chinese handset manufacturers, wearable devices, in-car connectivity and damaged iPhones.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

The rise of OTT messaging and the future of SMS: we talk to Stacy Adams of mBlox

Podcast - 7th March 2014

Messaging was very much on the agenda at Mobile World Congress this year, following Facebook's announcement that it was planning to acquire WhatsApp in a 19 billion dollar deal. So if the future for this type of internet-based 'over the top' messaging service looks good, what does this mean for SMS?

To find out more, we spoke to Stacy Adams of mBlox to learn what was happening in the messaging world, to find out how SMS is being integrated with mobile apps - and to discover some of the other ways SMS was being used by businesses today.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating

We talk about 4G LTE coverage and device sensors with OpenSignal at Mobile World Congress

Podcast - 6th March 2014

Even at Mobile World Congress, the relevance of the mobile network operator can sometimes be forgotten. So for a different perspective on this year's event, we spoke to Samuel Johnston from British mobile crowd-sourcing firm OpenSignal.

Samuel discussed the announcements from MWC14 and OpenSignal's latest report into 4G LTE coverage around the world, as well as giving us an exclusive insight into OpenSignal's next research subject.

Author: The Fonecast
0 Comments
Article rating: No rating
RSS
First567810121314Last

Follow thefonecast.com

Twitter @TheFonecast RSS podcast feed
Find us on Facebook Subscribe free via iTunes

Archive Calendar

«April 2024»
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
25262728293031
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293012345

Archive

Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement